Files
gh-jamesrochabrun-skills-qa…/skills/qa-test-planner/references/figma_validation.md
2025-11-29 18:49:41 +08:00

346 lines
6.9 KiB
Markdown

# Figma Design Validation with MCP
Guide for validating UI implementation against Figma designs using Figma MCP.
---
## Prerequisites
**Required:**
- Figma MCP server configured
- Access to Figma design files
- Figma URLs for components/pages
**Setup:**
```bash
# Install Figma MCP (follow official docs)
# Configure API token
# Verify access to design files
```
---
## Validation Workflow
### Step 1: Get Design Specifications
**Using Figma MCP:**
```
"Get the specifications for the primary button from Figma file at [URL]"
Response includes:
- Dimensions (width, height)
- Colors (background, text, border)
- Typography (font, size, weight)
- Spacing (padding, margin)
- Border radius
- States (default, hover, active, disabled)
```
### Step 2: Inspect Implementation
**Browser DevTools:**
1. Inspect element
2. Check computed styles
3. Verify dimensions
4. Compare colors (use color picker)
5. Check typography
6. Test interactive states
### Step 3: Document Discrepancies
**Create test case or bug:**
```
TC-UI-001: Primary Button Visual Validation
Design (Figma):
- Size: 120x40px
- Background: #0066FF
- Border-radius: 8px
- Font: 16px Medium #FFFFFF
Implementation:
- Size: 120x40px ✓
- Background: #0052CC ✗ (wrong shade)
- Border-radius: 8px ✓
- Font: 16px Regular #FFFFFF ✗ (wrong weight)
Status: FAIL
Bugs: BUG-234, BUG-235
```
---
## What to Validate
### Layout & Spacing
- [ ] Component dimensions
- [ ] Padding (all sides)
- [ ] Margins
- [ ] Grid alignment
- [ ] Responsive breakpoints
- [ ] Container max-width
**Example Query:**
```
"Extract spacing values for the card component from Figma"
```
### Typography
- [ ] Font family
- [ ] Font size
- [ ] Font weight
- [ ] Line height
- [ ] Letter spacing
- [ ] Text color
- [ ] Text alignment
**Example Query:**
```
"Get typography specifications for all heading levels from Figma design system"
```
### Colors
- [ ] Background colors
- [ ] Text colors
- [ ] Border colors
- [ ] Shadow colors
- [ ] Gradient values
- [ ] Opacity values
**Example Query:**
```
"List all color tokens used in the navigation component"
```
### Components
- [ ] Icon sizes and colors
- [ ] Button states
- [ ] Input field styling
- [ ] Checkbox/radio appearance
- [ ] Dropdown styling
- [ ] Card components
**Example Query:**
```
"Compare the implemented dropdown menu with Figma design at [URL]"
```
### Interactive States
- [ ] Default state
- [ ] Hover state
- [ ] Active/pressed state
- [ ] Focus state
- [ ] Disabled state
- [ ] Loading state
- [ ] Error state
---
## Common Discrepancies
### Typography Mismatches
- Wrong font weight (e.g., Regular instead of Medium)
- Incorrect font size
- Missing line-height
- Color hex codes off by a shade
### Spacing Issues
- Padding not matching
- Inconsistent margins
- Grid misalignment
- Component spacing varies
### Color Differences
- Hex values off (#0066FF vs #0052CC)
- Opacity not applied
- Gradient angles wrong
- Shadow colors incorrect
### Responsive Behavior
- Breakpoints don't match
- Mobile layout different
- Tablet view inconsistent
- Scaling not as designed
---
## Test Case Template
```markdown
## TC-UI-XXX: [Component] Visual Validation
**Figma Design:** [URL to specific component]
### Desktop (1920x1080)
**Layout:**
- [ ] Width: XXXpx
- [ ] Height: XXXpx
- [ ] Padding: XXpx XXpx XXpx XXpx
- [ ] Margin: XXpx
**Typography:**
- [ ] Font: [Family] [Weight]
- [ ] Size: XXpx
- [ ] Line-height: XXpx
- [ ] Color: #XXXXXX
**Colors:**
- [ ] Background: #XXXXXX
- [ ] Border: Xpx solid #XXXXXX
- [ ] Shadow: XXpx XXpx XXpx rgba(X,X,X,X)
**Interactive States:**
- [ ] Hover: [changes]
- [ ] Active: [changes]
- [ ] Focus: [changes]
- [ ] Disabled: [changes]
### Tablet (768px)
- [ ] [Responsive changes]
### Mobile (375px)
- [ ] [Responsive changes]
### Status
- [ ] PASS - All match
- [ ] FAIL - Discrepancies found
- [ ] BLOCKED - Design incomplete
```
---
## Figma MCP Queries
### Component Specifications
```
"Get complete specifications for the [component name] from Figma at [URL]"
"Extract all button variants from the design system"
"List typography styles defined in Figma"
```
### Color System
```
"Show me all color tokens in the Figma design system"
"What colors are used in the navigation bar design?"
"Get the exact hex values for primary, secondary, and accent colors"
```
### Spacing & Layout
```
"What are the padding values for the card component?"
"Extract grid specifications from the page layout"
"Get spacing tokens (8px, 16px, 24px, etc.)"
```
### Responsive Breakpoints
```
"What are the defined breakpoints in this Figma design?"
"Show mobile vs desktop layout differences for [component]"
```
---
## Bug Report for UI Discrepancies
```markdown
# BUG-XXX: [Component] doesn't match Figma design
**Severity:** Medium (UI)
**Type:** Visual
## Design vs Implementation
**Figma Design:** [URL]
**Expected (from Figma):**
- Button background: #0066FF
- Font weight: 600 (Semi-bold)
- Padding: 12px 24px
**Actual (in implementation):**
- Button background: #0052CC
- Font weight: 400 (Regular) ❌
- Padding: 12px 24px ✓
## Screenshots
- Figma design: [attach]
- Current implementation: [attach]
- Side-by-side comparison: [attach]
## Impact
Users see inconsistent branding. Button appears less prominent than designed.
```
---
## Automation Ideas
### Visual Regression Testing
- Capture screenshots
- Compare against Figma exports
- Highlight pixel differences
- Tools: Percy, Chromatic, BackstopJS
### Design Token Validation
- Extract Figma design tokens
- Compare with CSS variables
- Flag mismatches
- Automate with scripts
---
## Best Practices
**DO:**
- ✅ Always reference specific Figma URLs
- ✅ Test all component states
- ✅ Check responsive breakpoints
- ✅ Document exact values (not "close enough")
- ✅ Screenshot both design and implementation
- ✅ Test in multiple browsers
**DON'T:**
- ❌ Assume "it looks right"
- ❌ Skip hover/active states
- ❌ Ignore small color differences
- ❌ Test only on one screen size
- ❌ Forget to check typography
- ❌ Miss spacing issues
---
## Checklist for UI Test Cases
Per component:
- [ ] Figma URL documented
- [ ] Desktop layout validated
- [ ] Mobile/tablet responsive checked
- [ ] All interactive states tested
- [ ] Colors match exactly (use color picker)
- [ ] Typography specifications correct
- [ ] Spacing (padding/margins) accurate
- [ ] Icons match design
- [ ] Shadows/borders match
- [ ] Animations match timing/easing
---
## Quick Reference
| Element | What to Check | Tool |
|---------|---------------|------|
| Colors | Hex values exact | Browser color picker |
| Spacing | Padding/margin px | DevTools computed styles |
| Typography | Font, size, weight | DevTools font panel |
| Layout | Width, height, position | DevTools box model |
| States | Hover, active, focus | Manual interaction |
| Responsive | Breakpoint behavior | DevTools device mode |
---
**Remember:** Pixel-perfect implementation builds user trust and brand consistency.