gh-jamesrochabrun-skills-all-skills/skills/kids-book-writer/references/bestseller_elements.md

Bestseller Elements - What Makes Children's Books Successful

Research-backed elements found in bestselling, beloved children's books that have sold millions of copies and stood the test of time.

The Bestseller Formula

While there's no guaranteed formula, highly successful children's books consistently demonstrate:

Memorable Character
+ Emotional Resonance
+ Perfect Read-Aloud Experience
+ Re-Read Value
+ Adult Appeal
+ Universal Relatability
+ Unique Voice
= Bestseller Potential

Top 10 Elements of Bestselling Children's Books

1. Memorable, Lovable Characters

What Makes Characters Memorable:

• Distinct personality trait
• Unique voice
• Relatable struggles
• Endearing quirks
• Visual distinctiveness
• Name that's fun to say

Examples from Bestsellers:

The Pigeon (Don't Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus!)

• Personality: Persistent, whiny, hilarious
• Quirk: Desperately wants to drive the bus
• Why it works: Kids love saying "NO!" to authority figure

The Very Hungry Caterpillar

• Personality: Curious, growing
• Quirk: Eats through everything (literally)
• Why it works: Visual journey, transformation, counting

Elephant (Elephant & Piggie series)

• Personality: Cautious, worrying, caring
• Quirk: Overthinks everything
• Why it works: Paired with impulsive Piggie = perfect dynamic

Pete the Cat

• Personality: Chill, positive, cool
• Quirk: Says "It's all good" no matter what
• Why it works: Teaches resilience through groovy attitude

Common Traits:

• Can be described in 2-3 words
• Have catchphrase or repeated behavior
• Face problems kids relate to
• Show growth or teach lesson

2. Perfect Read-Aloud Rhythm

Why This Matters:

• Parents read books 100+ times
• Must be enjoyable for adult reader
• Rhythm makes memorization easy
• Kids join in on repeated lines

Techniques:

Rhyme (Dr. Seuss, Julia Donaldson):

"A mouse took a stroll through the deep dark wood.
A fox saw the mouse and the mouse looked good."
- The Gruffalo by Julia Donaldson

Perfect rhythm: Anapestic tetrameter
Memorable rhyme: wood/good
Read-aloud joy: Bouncy, flowing

Repetition (Bill Martin Jr.):

"Brown Bear, Brown Bear, what do you see?
I see a red bird looking at me.
Red Bird, Red Bird, what do you see?
I see a yellow duck looking at me."
- Brown Bear, Brown Bear, What Do You See?

Pattern: Predictable, cumulative
Participation: Kids memorize and "read" along

Rhythm without Rhyme (Margaret Wise Brown):

"In the great green room
There was a telephone
And a red balloon
And a picture of—"
- Goodnight Moon

Cadence: Soothing, rhythmic
Repetition: "And a..." structure
Bedtime perfect: Calm, sleepy rhythm

3. Emotional Resonance

Books That Make Kids (and Adults) Feel:

The Kissing Hand - Love and Security

• Taps into: Separation anxiety
• Emotional moment: Mom kisses hand so love goes with child
• Why it works: Provides comfort ritual families can adopt
• Sales: Over 7 million copies

The Giving Tree - Love and Sacrifice

• Taps into: Unconditional love, generosity
• Emotional moment: Tree gives everything
• Why it works: Moves both children and adults to tears
• Controversy: Debated message adds to discussion/sales

Where the Wild Things Are - Anger and Acceptance

• Taps into: Childhood anger, imagination, return to safety
• Emotional moment: "And Max said, 'Let the wild rumpus start!'"
• Why it works: Validates big emotions, provides safe resolution
• Impact: Over 19 million copies sold

How to Create Emotional Resonance:

• Tap into universal feelings (fear, love, joy, anger)
• Allow cathartic release
• Provide comfort or resolution
• Create "lump in throat" moments
• Show vulnerability
• Celebrate triumph

4. Interactive Elements

Why Interaction Drives Success:

• Engages child actively
• Creates game-like experience
• Increases re-read value
• Makes child feel part of story

Types of Interaction:

Call and Response:

"Don't let the pigeon drive the bus!"
(Kids shout: "NO!")

Finding/Seeking:

"Where's Spot?"
(Kids lift flaps to find Spot)

Counting/Learning:

"1 apple, 2 pears, 3 plums..."
(Kids count along)

Commands:

"Press the yellow dot."
(Kids touch the page)
- Press Here by Hervé Tullet

Participation:

"We're going on a bear hunt,
We're going to catch a big one!"
(Kids march and chant along)

5. Re-Read Value (Hidden Gems)

What Makes Books Worth Re-Reading:

Visual Details (Richard Scarry):

• Background full of tiny stories
• New discoveries each time
• Where's Waldo effect

Multiple Layers (Dr. Seuss):

• Kid level: Silly rhymes and pictures
• Adult level: Satire, deeper meaning
• Example: "The Lorax" - environmental message

Humor That Ages Well (Mo Willems):

• Slapstick for young kids
• Wit for older kids and adults
• Emotional depth underneath

Comforting Familiarity:

• Same book, same ritual
• Nostalgia factor
• Security of known story

How to Add Re-Read Value:

• Hide details in illustrations
• Layer meanings
• Add subtle humor for adults
• Create quotable lines
• Build world worth revisiting

6. Universal Relatability + Unique Specificity

The Balance:

Too General: "A kid learns to share"

• Not memorable, could be anyone

Too Specific: "A left-handed redheaded girl from Nebraska learns cricket"

• Too narrow, hard to relate

Perfect Balance: "Chrysanthemum loves her name until kids tease her"

• Universal: Name insecurity
• Specific: Unusual name "Chrysanthemum"
• Result: Bestseller (over 1 million copies)

Examples:

Pete the Cat: I Love My White Shoes

• Universal: Things going wrong, staying positive
• Specific: White shoes getting dirty
• Why it works: Every kid has messy shoes story

Corduroy

• Universal: Wanting to be loved, finding where you belong
• Specific: Teddy bear missing button
• Why it works: Object + emotion kids understand

The Snowy Day

• Universal: Joy of play, exploration
• Specific: Peter's experience of first snow
• Why it works: Simple wonder, beautiful illustrations

7. Satisfying Story Arc

Even Simple Books Need Structure:

The Very Hungry Caterpillar:

Beginning: Little egg
Rising: Caterpillar eats (and eats and eats)
Climax: Stomachache!
Resolution: Cocoon
Ending: Beautiful butterfly

Arc: Growth and transformation
Satisfaction: Visual, narrative, and metaphorical completion

Where the Wild Things Are:

Beginning: Max misbehaves
Journey: Sails to Wild Things
Climax: "Let the wild rumpus start!"
Turning point: Max feels lonely
Resolution: Sails home
Ending: Supper still warm

Arc: Out and back, anger and love
Satisfaction: Fantasy adventure with safe return

Elements of Satisfying Arc:

• Clear beginning
• Building tension or anticipation
• Climactic moment
• Resolution
• Emotional closure

8. Parent/Teacher Appeal

Books Succeed When Adults Love Them:

Parents Will Buy Books That:

• Teach without preaching
• Aren't annoying on repeat
• Have nostalgic quality
• Address real parenting concerns
• Are beautifully illustrated
• Become family traditions

Teachers Will Buy Books That:

• Support curriculum (counting, colors, letters, social-emotional)
• Spark discussions
• Work for read-alouds
• Engage diverse learners
• Address classroom dynamics
• Have teaching guides available

Multi-Generational Appeal:

"The Giving Tree" - Debated for 50+ years
"Goodnight Moon" - Bedtime ritual since 1947
"The Very Hungry Caterpillar" - Teaching tool and comfort read

9. Distinctive Illustration Style

Visual Identity Matters:

Eric Carle - Tissue Paper Collage

• Instantly recognizable
• Bold, simple, beautiful
• The Very Hungry Caterpillar: 50+ million copies

Mo Willems - Simple Line Drawings

• Expressive despite simplicity
• Humor in facial expressions
• Elephant & Piggie: 8+ million copies

Beatrix Potter - Detailed Watercolors

• Classic, timeless
• Realistic yet whimsical
• Peter Rabbit: 150+ million copies

Why Distinctive Art Sells:

• Brand recognition
• Shelf appeal
• Collectability
• Merchandising potential
• Emotional connection to style

10. Strong Opening Hook

First Page Must Grab Attention:

Immediate Character:

"I'm the best."
- I Am the Best by Lucy Cousins

Hook: Confident, bold statement
Works: Kids want to know who's talking

Immediate Problem:

"David's teacher always said... 'No, David!'"
- No, David! by David Shannon

Hook: Kid in trouble (relatable!)
Works: Every kid knows this feeling

Immediate Wonder:

"In the light of the moon a little egg lay on a leaf."
- The Very Hungry Caterpillar

Hook: Beautiful imagery, promise of transformation
Works: Sets magical, anticipatory tone

Immediate Humor:

"Diary of a Wombat: Monday - Slept. Tuesday - Slept."
- Diary of a Wombat by Jackie French

Hook: Funny, deadpan humor
Works: Adults and kids both laugh

Case Studies: Bestseller Breakdown

"The Gruffalo" - 13.5 Million Copies Sold

Why It's a Bestseller:

✅ Perfect Rhyme and Rhythm

• Anapestic tetrameter throughout
• Singable, memorable cadence
• Read-aloud joy

✅ Clever Story Structure

• Mouse invents Gruffalo to scare predators
• Gruffalo becomes real
• Mouse uses wits to scare Gruffalo
• Circular, satisfying

✅ Memorable Character

• The Gruffalo: Described in detail (terrible tusks, terrible claws)
• Mouse: Small but clever
• David beats Goliath archetype

✅ Repeating Pattern

• Three predators (fox, owl, snake)
• Repetition builds anticipation
• Kids can predict and participate

✅ Gorgeous Illustrations

• Axel Scheffler's distinctive style
• Rich forest setting
• Expressive characters

✅ Theme

• Intelligence over strength
• Creativity (mouse's imagination)
• Empowerment for small kids

"Pete the Cat: I Love My White Shoes" - 9+ Million Copies

Why It's a Bestseller:

✅ Catchy Song

• "I love my white shoes" repeated
• Melody made it viral
• Kids sing it everywhere

✅ Growth Mindset Message

• Things go wrong (shoes get dirty)
• Pete stays positive
• "It's all good" attitude
• Parents love teaching resilience

✅ Repetitive Structure

• Shoes get dirty
• Color changes
• Pete sings anyway
• Pattern kids can predict

✅ Cool Character

• Pete is chill, sunglasses-wearing cat
• Kids want to be like Pete
• Catchphrase: "I love my [color] shoes"

✅ Merchandising

• Plush toys
• Shoes
• Songs
• Apps
• Brand expansion

"Goodnight Moon" - 48+ Million Copies

Why It's a Classic:

✅ Perfect Bedtime Rhythm

• Soothing, rhythmic prose
• Gets slower, quieter
• Lulls child to sleep

✅ Ritual and Routine

• Saying goodnight to everything
• Creates bedtime ritual families adopt
• Comforting pattern

✅ Visual Journey

• Room gets darker page by page
• Shadows lengthen
• Details to find (mouse on every page)

✅ Simple, Profound

• Says goodnight to mundane objects
• Elevates ordinary
• Validates child's world

✅ Timeless Quality

• Published 1947, still selling
• Nostalgia factor huge
• Multi-generational tradition

Elements to Avoid

❌ Trends Over Timelessness

Avoid:

• Current slang ("That's so random!")
• Technology that dates quickly
• Trendy topics

Embrace:

• Universal emotions
• Timeless situations
• Classic language

❌ Talking Down to Kids

Avoid:

• Oversimplification
• Condescension
• Explaining everything

Embrace:

• Trusting kids' intelligence
• Leaving room for imagination
• Sophisticated vocabulary in context

❌ Complex Morals Without Story

Avoid:

• Lecturing
• Abstract concepts without narrative
• Adult problems in kid packaging

Embrace:

• Story first
• Age-appropriate themes
• Natural lesson integration

❌ Inconsistent Tone

Avoid:

• Mixing serious and silly randomly
• Confusing messages
• Jarring style shifts

Embrace:

• Consistent voice
• Intentional tone
• Cohesive experience

The Bestseller Checklist

Before submitting your manuscript, ask:

Character:

• Can character be described in 2-3 words?
• Does character have distinct voice?
• Will kids want to be/befriend this character?

Story:

• Clear beginning, middle, end?
• Stakes appropriate for age?
• Satisfying resolution?

Read-Aloud:

• Enjoyable to read 100+ times?
• Good rhythm (rhyme or prose)?
• Quotable lines?

Emotional Resonance:

• Does it make you feel something?
• Will it move children?
• Universal emotion tapped?

Re-Read Value:

• New discoveries on re-reads?
• Hidden details?
• Layers of meaning?

Practical Appeal:

• Will parents want to buy it?
• Will teachers use it?
• Gift-worthy?

Uniqueness:

• Something new/fresh in concept or execution?
• Memorable premise?
• Stands out on shelf?

Timelessness:

• Will this matter in 10 years?
• Avoids trendy language?
• Universal themes?

Publishing Market Insights

What's Selling in 2025:

Evergreen Topics:

• First experiences (school, friends)
• Emotions and self-regulation
• Kindness and inclusion
• Growth mindset
• STEM concepts (accessible)
• Bedtime books (always!)

Growing Markets:

• Diverse representation
• Social-emotional learning
• Interactive books
• Books addressing anxiety
• Empowerment themes
• Environmental awareness

Series vs. Standalone:

• Series build loyal following
• Standalone easier to sell as debut
• Character-driven series potential goldmine

Summary

Bestselling children's books consistently:

• Create memorable characters
• Provide perfect read-aloud experience
• Resonate emotionally
• Offer re-read value
• Balance universal and specific
• Have satisfying story arcs
• Appeal to adults and children
• Feature distinctive illustrations
• Hook readers immediately
• Stand the test of time

"Write the book that children will love, parents won't mind reading 100 times, and everyone will remember forever."