2.4 KiB
2.4 KiB
Baseline Quality Assessment Components
Purpose: V_meta(s₀) calculation components for strong iteration 0 Target: V_meta(s₀) ≥ 0.40 for rapid convergence
Formula
V_meta(s₀) = 0.4 × completeness +
0.3 × transferability +
0.3 × automation_effectiveness
Component 1: Completeness (40%)
Definition: Initial pattern/taxonomy coverage
Calculation:
completeness = initial_items / estimated_final_items
Achieve ≥0.50:
- Analyze ALL available data (3-5 hours)
- Create 10-15 initial categories/patterns
- Classify ≥70% of observed cases
Example (Error Recovery):
Initial: 10 categories (1,056/1,336 = 79.1% coverage)
Estimated final: 12-13 categories
Completeness: 10/12.5 = 0.80
Contribution: 0.4 × 0.80 = 0.32
Component 2: Transferability (30%)
Definition: Reusable patterns from prior art
Calculation:
transferability = borrowed_patterns / total_patterns_needed
Achieve ≥0.30:
- Research similar methodologies (1-2 hours)
- Identify industry standards
- Document borrowable patterns (≥30%)
Example (Error Recovery):
Borrowed: 5 industry error patterns
Total needed: ~10
Transferability: 5/10 = 0.50
Contribution: 0.3 × 0.50 = 0.15
Component 3: Automation (30%)
Definition: Early identification of high-ROI automation
Calculation:
automation_effectiveness = identified_tools / expected_tools
Achieve ≥0.30:
- Frequency analysis (1 hour)
- Identify top 3-5 automation candidates
- Estimate ROI (≥5x)
Example (Error Recovery):
Identified: 3 tools (all with >20x ROI)
Expected final: 3 tools
Automation: 3/3 = 1.0
Contribution: 0.3 × 1.0 = 0.30
Quality Levels
Excellent (V_meta ≥ 0.60)
Achieves:
- Completeness: ≥0.70
- Transferability: ≥0.60
- Automation: ≥0.70
Effort: 6-10 hours Outcome: 3-4 iterations
Good (V_meta = 0.40-0.59)
Achieves:
- Completeness: ≥0.50
- Transferability: ≥0.30
- Automation: ≥0.30
Effort: 4-6 hours Outcome: 4-5 iterations
Fair (V_meta = 0.20-0.39)
Achieves:
- Completeness: 0.30-0.50
- Transferability: 0.20-0.30
- Automation: 0.20-0.30
Effort: 2-4 hours Outcome: 5-7 iterations
Poor (V_meta < 0.20)
Indicates:
- Minimal baseline work
- Exploratory phase needed
Effort: <2 hours Outcome: 7-10 iterations
Source: BAIME Baseline Quality Assessment