# Validate PRP Quality

## PRP File: $ARGUMENTS

Review a PRP (Pre-Requirements Plan) file for completeness and implementation readiness.

## Validation Checklist

### Research and Context

- [ ] All research context included with URLs
- [ ] Tech stack properly identified (framework, build tools, testing)
- [ ] External documentation links provided
- [ ] Code examples from codebase referenced

### Implementation Planning

- [ ] Implementation phases clearly defined
- [ ] Each phase has specific deliverables
- [ ] Validation commands match project setup
- [ ] Manual testing steps provided for each phase

### Technical Details

- [ ] Error handling strategy documented
- [ ] Existing patterns properly referenced
- [ ] Incremental milestones defined
- [ ] Edge cases considered

### Execution Readiness

- [ ] All TODOs and placeholders resolved
- [ ] Dependencies clearly listed
- [ ] Environment setup documented
- [ ] Success criteria measurable

## Analysis Process

1. **Structural Review**
   - Check for all required PRP sections
   - Verify phase breakdown is logical
   - Ensure validation points are clear

2. **Technical Assessment**
   - Validate that tech stack matches project
   - Check if referenced patterns exist in codebase
   - Confirm validation commands will work

3. **Completeness Check**
   - Scan for missing implementation details
   - Identify any ambiguous requirements
   - Flag incomplete research areas

## Output

### Quality Score (1-10)

Rate the PRP's readiness for execution:

- **1-3**: Major gaps, needs significant work
- **4-6**: Good foundation, some areas need completion
- **7-8**: Well-defined, minor improvements possible
- **9-10**: Comprehensive and execution-ready

### Feedback Report

- **Strengths**: What the PRP does well
- **Missing Elements**: Critical gaps to address
- **Research Gaps**: Areas needing more documentation
- **Implementation Concerns**: Potential execution challenges

### Recommended Actions

- **Ready to execute**: Proceed with `/execute-prp`
- **Needs completion**: Specific sections to enhance
- **Requires validation**: Commands to verify first
- **Research needed**: External resources to gather