Files
gh-lyndonkl-claude/skills/memory-retrieval-learning/resources/methodology.md
2025-11-30 08:38:26 +08:00

15 KiB
Raw Blame History

Advanced Memory & Learning Methodology

Workflow

Advanced Learning Progress:
- [ ] Step 1: Diagnose learning challenges
- [ ] Step 2: Select advanced techniques
- [ ] Step 3: Optimize spacing algorithm
- [ ] Step 4: Address motivation and habits
- [ ] Step 5: Break through plateaus
- [ ] Step 6: Maintain long-term retention

Step 1: Diagnose learning challenges

Identify specific problems: interference between similar concepts, motivation decay, learning plateaus, or retention below 60%. See 1. Diagnostic Framework.

Step 2: Select advanced techniques

Choose from desirable difficulties, elaborative interrogation, dual coding, or generation effect based on material type. See 2. Advanced Techniques.

Step 3: Optimize spacing algorithm

Adjust intervals based on material difficulty, personal retention curves, and interference patterns. See 3. Optimizing Spaced Repetition.

Step 4: Address motivation and habits

Build sustainable learning habits using implementation intentions, temptation bundling, and progress visualization. See 4. Motivation & Habit Formation.

Step 5: Break through plateaus

Use targeted strategies for overcoming learning stalls: difficulty increase, context variation, or deliberate practice. See 5. Breaking Plateaus.

Step 6: Maintain long-term retention

Implement maintenance schedules, periodic reactivation, and knowledge gardening. See 6. Long-Term Maintenance.


1. Diagnostic Framework

Common Learning Problems

Problem: Forgetting too quickly (retention <60%)

  • Symptoms: Failing Day 3/7 reviews, relearning from scratch, can't recall basics
  • Causes: Shallow encoding, interference, insufficient elaboration, sleep deprivation
  • Solutions: Spend 2x longer initially, use 1-2-4-8-16 day schedule, add "A vs B" comparisons, prioritize 7-9hr sleep

Problem: Learning plateau (no improvement for 3+ weeks)

  • Symptoms: Mock test scores stuck, retention flat, effort feels wasted
  • Causes: Wrong difficulty level, no error feedback, insufficient variation, metacognitive illusions
  • Solutions: Use 85% rule (succeed 85%, fail 15%), immediate feedback, increase variation, predict scores pre-test

Problem: Motivation decay

  • Symptoms: Skipping sessions, dreading materials, procrastinating, questioning purpose
  • Causes: Distant goals, no intrinsic interest, no progress visibility, burnout
  • Solutions: Weekly milestones, link to personal interests, visualize progress, reduce daily time 30%

2. Advanced Techniques

Desirable Difficulties

Concept: Making retrieval harder (within limits) strengthens long-term retention.

Applications:

Varied Practice Contexts:

  • Study same material in different locations (library, café, home)
  • Different times of day
  • With/without background music
  • Standing vs sitting
  • Effect: Breaks context-dependent memory, aids transfer

Generation Effect:

  • Generate answer before seeing it (even if wrong guess)
  • Fill-in-the-blank > multiple choice > recognition
  • Summarize in own words before reading summary
  • Effect: Effortful generation strengthens encoding

Spacing with Optimal Difficulty:

  • Space reviews such that retention is 50-80% (not 90%+)
  • Too easy = wasted time
  • Too hard (<40%) = frustration, no benefit
  • Sweet spot: Struggling but succeeding most of the time

Elaborative Interrogation

Technique: Ask "why" questions to connect new knowledge to existing schemas.

Process:

  1. Learn new fact: "Mitochondria are the powerhouse of the cell"
  2. Ask: "Why do cells need a powerhouse?"
  3. Answer: "Because they need energy for all cellular processes"
  4. Ask: "Why is this energy generation separated into mitochondria?"
  5. Answer: "Because it involves complex chemistry that's isolated for safety/efficiency"

Benefits:

  • Creates retrieval routes through elaboration
  • Integrates isolated facts into knowledge networks
  • Reveals understanding gaps

When to use:

  • Conceptual material (not pure memorization)
  • When facts seem arbitrary or disconnected
  • Building mental models of systems

Dual Coding

Concept: Combine verbal and visual representations for redundant encoding.

Applications:

For Abstract Concepts:

  • Draw diagram while explaining verbally
  • Use metaphor + literal definition
  • Create mind map + written outline
  • Benefit: Two retrieval paths instead of one

For Procedures:

  • Watch video demonstration + read step-by-step text
  • Create flowchart + write algorithm
  • Use physical gesture + verbal description (embodied cognition)

For Vocabulary:

  • Word + image flashcard
  • Etymology (visual word parts) + definition
  • Example sentence + picture of scenario

Evidence: Dual coding increases recall by 20-30% compared to single modality.

Interleaving vs. Blocking

Blocked Practice: AAAA BBBB CCCC (all of topic A, then all of B, then all of C) Interleaved Practice: ABCABC ABCABC (mix topics within session)

When to Use Each:

Use Blocking (AAAA) when:

  • Complete novice learning brand new skill
  • First exposure to topic (need to establish basics)
  • Material is extremely difficult
  • Example: Day 1 of learning Python loops, do 10 loop problems in a row

Use Interleaving (ABCABC) when:

  • Past initial learning phase
  • Multiple similar concepts to discriminate
  • Preparing for tests (which are always interleaved)
  • Example: After learning loops, functions, classes → mix all three in practice

Interleaving Benefits:

  • +40% improvement in discrimination between similar concepts
  • Better transfer to novel problems
  • Reveals confusion between topics (forces discrimination)

Interleaving Costs:

  • Feels harder and less productive during practice
  • Initial performance worse than blocking
  • Requires trust in the process

3. Optimizing Spaced Repetition

Beyond Standard Intervals

Standard Schedule: 1-3-7-14-30 days works for average retention.

Personalized Optimization:

If you're a fast forgetter:

  • Use: 1-2-4-8-16-32 day intervals
  • More frequent early reviews
  • Accept that you'll review more often

If you're a slow forgetter:

  • Use: 1-4-10-25-60 day intervals
  • Extend intervals to save time
  • Only review when approaching forgetting

Measuring Your Retention Curve:

  1. After learning something, test retention at Days 1, 3, 7, 14
  2. Plot % retained vs. days since learning
  3. Find when retention drops to 70%
  4. That's your optimal review timing

Material-Specific Intervals

High-Interference Material (similar concepts that confuse each other):

  • Use shorter intervals: 1-2-4-7-14 days
  • Add contrastive examples every review
  • Example: Spanish/Italian vocab (similar languages)

Low-Interference Material (isolated, distinctive):

  • Use longer intervals: 1-4-12-30-90 days
  • Example: Anatomy terms (distinctive body parts)

Procedural Knowledge:

  • Compress early intervals: 1-1-2-4-8 days (more practice initially)
  • Then extend: 15-30-60 days for maintenance
  • Example: Keyboard shortcuts, coding syntax

Conceptual Understanding:

  • Standard or extended intervals: 1-3-7-21-60 days
  • Focus on elaboration each review, not just recall
  • Example: Physics principles, business models

Adaptive Algorithms

Manual Leitner System:

  • Box 1: Daily review
  • Box 2: Every 3 days
  • Box 3: Weekly
  • Box 4: Bi-weekly
  • Box 5: Monthly
  • Move forward on success, back to Box 1 on failure

SuperMemo SM-2 Algorithm (used by Anki):

If correct:
  New interval = Old interval × Ease Factor

If forgotten:
  Restart at Day 1
  Reduce Ease Factor (make future intervals shorter)

Ease Factor adjusts based on how hard each card is for you

When to Use Software:

  • 100+ items to review (manual tracking gets overwhelming)
  • Long-term projects (6+ months)
  • Need mobile access for anywhere review
  • Want automatic scheduling optimization

4. Motivation & Habit Formation

Implementation Intentions

Format: "When [situation], I will [behavior]"

Examples:

  • "When I finish breakfast, I will review flashcards for 15 minutes"
  • "When I arrive at library, I will do one practice problem set"
  • "When I feel stuck on a problem, I will take 5-min break then return"

Why it works:

  • Removes decision fatigue ("should I study now?")
  • Creates automatic triggers
  • 2-3x higher follow-through than vague goals

Creating Effective Implementation Intentions:

  1. Choose consistent trigger (same time, place, or prior event)
  2. Start with laughably easy behavior (10 minutes, not 2 hours)
  3. Reward immediately after (walk, snack, favorite activity)
  4. Track completion (checkbox satisfaction)

Temptation Bundling

Concept: Pair desirable activity with learning to transfer motivation.

Examples:

  • Only listen to favorite podcast while reviewing flashcards
  • Drink premium coffee only during study sessions
  • Watch one episode of show after completing daily goal
  • Study at favorite café with great ambiance

Setup:

  1. Identify guilty pleasure or desired activity
  2. Make it contingent on study session
  3. Never allow pleasure without study (strict bundling)
  4. Result: Pavlovian association forms

Progress Visualization

Techniques:

Completion Tracking:

  • Visual: Mark off each unit completed on printed grid
  • Quantitative: "35/100 topics mastered"
  • Milestone: "Halfway through, 8 weeks to go"

Streak Tracking:

  • Days in a row completing review
  • Motivating to maintain streak
  • But: Build in guilt-free "break days" (1 per week allowed)

Score Improvement:

  • Graph mock test scores over time
  • Even flat line with uptick at end is progress
  • Compare to initial baseline, not perfection

Time Investment:

  • Total hours invested visual (fills up jar/thermometer)
  • Sunk cost becomes motivating: "I've put in 40 hours, not quitting now"

5. Breaking Plateaus

Diagnose Plateau Type

Knowledge Plateau:

  • You know the basics but can't advance
  • Solution: Deliberate practice on weakest areas (not random review)
  • Find the specific sub-skill holding you back

Transfer Plateau:

  • Can answer practice questions but fail novel problems
  • Solution: Increase variation, practice with different formats/contexts
  • Interleave more aggressively

Speed Plateau:

  • Accurate but too slow
  • Solution: Timed practice with progressive time pressure
  • Chunking (automate sub-routines)

Strategies by Plateau Type

For Knowledge Plateaus:

  1. Error Analysis:

    • Review last 20 errors in detail
    • Categorize: Careless? Conceptual gap? Never learned?
    • Create targeted mini-lessons for gaps
  2. Prerequisite Check:

    • Are you missing foundational knowledge?
    • Go back 1-2 levels, fill gaps
    • Example: Struggling with calculus? Review algebra
  3. Increase Difficulty:

    • 85% rule: Should succeed 85% of time
    • If above 95%, material is too easy
    • Find harder problems/questions

For Transfer Plateaus:

  1. Far Transfer Practice:

    • Apply knowledge in completely new domains
    • Example: Learn stats with sports, apply to business
    • Forces deep understanding beyond memorized procedures
  2. Explain to Novice:

    • Teach material to someone who knows nothing
    • Forces simple explanations, reveals assumption gaps
    • Can't hide behind jargon

For Speed Plateaus:

  1. Chunking:

    • Identify repeated sub-procedures
    • Practice sub-procedures until automatic
    • Example: Typing → practice common letter pairs
  2. Timed Progressive Overload:

    • Week 1: Complete problem set, no time limit
    • Week 2: Same set in 90% of Week 1 time
    • Week 3: 80% of Week 1 time
    • Build speed without sacrificing accuracy

6. Long-Term Maintenance

Maintenance Schedules

After achieving proficiency, prevent forgetting:

High-Stakes Knowledge (exam, job-critical):

  • Review every 60-90 days
  • Do mini-refresher (15-30 min)
  • One practice problem set quarterly
  • Example: Maintaining coding skills between projects

Medium-Stakes (nice to have, occasional use):

  • Review every 6 months
  • Quick skim + one example
  • 10-15 min refresher
  • Example: Foreign language you use on vacation

Low-Stakes (personal interest):

  • Review yearly or when needed
  • Accept some forgetting (quick relearn as needed)
  • Example: Hobby knowledge like wine regions

Periodic Reactivation

Concept: Brief reactivation prevents dormancy.

Technique:

  • Set calendar reminder every X months
  • Spend 15-30 minutes on representative sample
  • Don't re-study everything, just key concepts/skills
  • If retention >70%, extend next review interval
  • If retention <50%, schedule intensive review

Knowledge Gardening

Metaphor: Knowledge is a garden requiring maintenance.

Practices:

Weeding:

  • Retire outdated knowledge (old APIs, superseded methods)
  • Don't maintain what's no longer useful
  • Example: Remove Windows XP skills if not relevant

Pruning:

  • Identify rarely-retrieved knowledge
  • Let it fade if truly not needed
  • Focus maintenance on high-value knowledge

Feeding:

  • Add new knowledge to existing networks
  • Update as field evolves
  • Example: Add new Python 3.12 features to existing Python knowledge

Cross-Pollination:

  • Connect knowledge across domains
  • Strengthens both through analogies
  • Example: Link economics concepts to psychology

7. Troubleshooting Guide

If motivation collapses: → Reduce daily time by 50%, add rewards, reconnect to purpose

If retention drops below 60%: → Shorten intervals (use 1-2-4-8-16 schedule), add elaboration, check sleep

If learning feels effortless (>95% retention): → Extend intervals, increase difficulty, you're wasting time on too-easy material

If similar concepts interfere: → Use contrastive examples, space their learning apart by 1-2 days, create comparison charts

If plateau for 3+ weeks: → Diagnose type (knowledge/transfer/speed), apply targeted strategy from Section 5

If burnout symptoms appear: → Take 3-7 day break, reduce load 50%, switch to intrinsically interesting material

If can't find time: → 15 min minimum daily beats 2 hr weekly, use implementation intentions, temptation bundling


When to Apply This Methodology

Use advanced methodology when:

✓ Standard spaced repetition isn't working (retention <60%) ✓ Learning plateau persists despite consistent effort ✓ Motivation is declining over time ✓ Material has high interference (similar concepts confusing) ✓ Long-term retention critical (6+ months, professional knowledge) ✓ Preparing for very high-stakes outcomes (medical boards, bar exam) ✓ Need to optimize efficiency (limited time, many topics)

Use standard template.md when: ✗ First time using spaced repetition (start simple) ✗ Short-term goals (< 3 months) ✗ Material is straightforward with low interference ✗ Standard intervals (1-3-7-14-30) are working fine