9.7 KiB
9.7 KiB
Clinical Report Quality Assurance Checklist
General Quality Standards
Completeness
- All required sections present
- No blank fields or missing information
- All relevant clinical information included
- Timeline of events clear and complete
- All diagnostic tests and results documented
- All treatments and interventions documented
- Follow-up plan specified
Accuracy
- Patient demographics correct
- Dates and times accurate
- Laboratory values with correct units and reference ranges
- Medication names, doses, and frequencies correct
- Diagnoses coded correctly (ICD-10)
- Procedures coded correctly (CPT if applicable)
- No contradictory information
Clarity
- Clear, professional language
- Medical terminology used appropriately
- Abbreviations defined or standard only
- Logical organization and flow
- Legible (if handwritten)
- No ambiguous statements
- Clinical reasoning clearly explained
Timeliness
- Documented in real-time or shortly after encounter
- Discharge summary completed within 24-48 hours
- Critical results communicated immediately
- Regulatory reporting deadlines met
Case Report Quality Checklist
CARE Guidelines Compliance
- Title includes "case report"
- Keywords provided (2-5 MeSH terms)
- Structured abstract with all elements
- Introduction explains novelty
- Patient information present and de-identified
- Clinical findings documented
- Timeline provided (table or figure)
- Diagnostic assessment detailed
- Therapeutic interventions described
- Follow-up and outcomes reported
- Discussion with literature review
- Patient perspective included (if possible)
- Informed consent statement present
Privacy and Ethics
- Informed consent obtained and documented
- All 18 HIPAA identifiers removed
- Dates removed or approximated
- Ages reported appropriately (>89 aggregated)
- Geographic information limited to state
- Images de-identified or consented
- IRB approval if applicable
Scientific Quality
- Novelty clearly established
- Literature search comprehensive
- Differential diagnosis considered
- Causality addressed
- Limitations acknowledged
- Learning points actionable
- References current and relevant
Clinical Trial Report Quality Checklist
SAE Report Checklist
- All administrative information complete
- Subject de-identified (ID number only)
- Event description detailed
- MedDRA coding applied
- Seriousness criteria documented
- Severity assessed
- Outcome specified
- Causality assessment completed with rationale
- Expectedness determined
- Action taken with study drug documented
- Treatment for event described
- Narrative comprehensive and chronological
- Critical findings communicated if applicable
- Regulatory timelines met (7-day, 15-day)
Clinical Study Report (CSR) Checklist
- ICH-E3 structure followed
- Synopsis complete and accurate
- All sections numbered correctly
- Abbreviations defined
- Ethics approvals documented
- Investigator list complete
- Study design clearly described
- Sample size justified
- Statistical methods specified
- CONSORT diagram included
- Baseline demographics table
- Primary endpoint results
- All secondary endpoints reported
- Adverse events summarized
- Individual SAE narratives included
- Discussion and conclusions present
- Appendices complete (protocol, CRFs, etc.)
Diagnostic Report Quality Checklist
Radiology Report
- Patient demographics complete
- Clinical indication documented
- Comparison studies noted
- Technique described
- Findings systematic and comprehensive
- Measurements provided for abnormalities
- Impression summarizes key findings
- Answers clinical question
- Recommendations specified
- Critical results communicated
- Structured reporting used if applicable (BI-RADS, Lung-RADS, etc.)
- Report signed and dated
Pathology Report
- Specimen labeled correctly
- Clinical history provided
- Gross description detailed
- Microscopic description comprehensive
- Diagnosis clear and specific
- Cancer staging complete (if applicable)
- Margins documented
- Lymph nodes quantified
- Synoptic reporting used for cancer (CAP protocol)
- Immunohistochemistry results included
- Molecular results included if applicable
- Report signed by pathologist
Laboratory Report
- Specimen type documented
- Collection time documented
- Results with units
- Reference ranges provided
- Critical values flagged
- Critical values communicated
- Specimen quality noted
- Methodology specified (if relevant)
- Interpretation provided (when applicable)
- LOINC codes assigned (for interoperability)
- Report signed and dated
Patient Documentation Quality Checklist
SOAP Note
- Chief complaint documented
- HPI comprehensive (≥4 elements)
- Review of systems performed
- Vital signs recorded
- Physical exam documented (relevant systems)
- Assessment with differential diagnosis
- Plan specific and actionable
- Return precautions provided
- Follow-up arranged
- Documentation supports billing level
- Signed, dated, and timed
History and Physical (H&P)
- Chief complaint
- Detailed HPI
- Past medical history
- Past surgical history
- Medications reconciled
- Allergies documented
- Family history
- Social history
- Review of systems (≥10 systems for comprehensive)
- Complete physical exam (≥8 systems)
- Laboratory and imaging results
- Assessment and plan for each problem
- Code status documented
- Completed within 24 hours of admission
- Signed and cosigned (if required)
Discharge Summary
- Admission and discharge dates
- Length of stay
- Admission diagnosis
- Discharge diagnoses (ICD-10 coded)
- Hospital course narrative
- Procedures performed
- Discharge medications reconciled
- New/changed/discontinued medications clearly marked
- Discharge condition
- Discharge disposition
- Follow-up appointments
- Patient instructions
- Return precautions
- Pending tests documented
- Code status
- Completed within 24-48 hours
- Sent to outpatient providers
Regulatory Compliance Checklist
HIPAA Compliance
- Only minimum necessary PHI disclosed
- PHI secured and protected
- Patient authorization obtained (if required)
- Business associate agreement (if applicable)
- Audit trail maintained (electronic records)
- Breach notification procedures followed
- De-identification performed correctly
FDA/ICH-GCP Compliance (Clinical Trials)
- GCP principles followed
- Informed consent documented
- IRB approval current
- Protocol adherence documented
- Source documentation adequate
- ALCOA-CCEA principles met
- 21 CFR Part 11 compliance (electronic records)
- Safety reporting timelines met
- Essential documents maintained
Writing Quality Checklist
Grammar and Style
- Correct spelling
- Proper grammar
- Appropriate punctuation
- Consistent verb tense
- Professional tone
- Objective language
- No personal pronouns in formal reports
- Active voice used appropriately
Format and Presentation
- Consistent formatting
- Appropriate font and size
- Adequate margins
- Page numbers (if applicable)
- Headers/footers appropriate
- Tables properly formatted with labels
- Figures high quality with legends
- References formatted correctly
Medical Terminology
- Terminology accurate
- Abbreviations standard only
- Abbreviations defined on first use
- Units of measurement correct
- Drug names correct (generic preferred)
- Anatomical terms correct
- Coding accurate (ICD-10, CPT, MedDRA)
Documentation Integrity Checklist
Legal and Ethical Standards
- Facts documented, not opinions
- Patient quotes when relevant
- Non-compliance documented objectively
- No alterations to original record
- Addendums used for corrections
- Addendums clearly labeled
- All entries signed and dated
- Authorship clear
Billing and Coding Support
- Medical necessity documented
- Complexity of care documented
- Time documented (if time-based billing)
- ICD-10 codes appropriate and specific
- CPT codes match documented services
- Modifiers appropriate
- Documentation supports level of service billed
Final Review Checklist
Before finalizing any clinical report:
- Read through entire document
- Check for completeness
- Verify all data accuracy
- Ensure logical flow
- Check spelling and grammar
- Verify patient identifiers correct (or removed if de-identified)
- Ensure compliance with regulations
- Confirm all required signatures
- Verify proper distribution
- Archive copy appropriately
Quality Metrics to Track
- Report turnaround time
- Amendment/addendum rate
- Critical value communication time
- Completeness score
- Accuracy rate (errors per report)
- Compliance rate
- Patient safety events related to documentation
- Peer review feedback
Quality Assurance Reviewer:
Name: ____________________
Date: ____________________
Signature: ____________________
Quality Score: _____ / 100
Issues Identified:
- [Issue and recommendation]
- [Issue and recommendation]
Follow-up Required: [ ] Yes [ ] No