zhongwei/gh-jschulte-claude-plugins-stackshift
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
f8e59e249cce33110561d850722fabbce95271ff
gh-jschulte-claude-plugins-…/skills/analyze/operations/completeness-assessment.md
Zhongwei Li f8e59e249c Initial commit
2025-11-30 08:29:31 +08:00

9.3 KiB
Raw Blame History

Completeness Assessment

Assess how complete the application implementation is.

Overview

Estimate the percentage completion for:

  • Overall application
  • Backend implementation
  • Frontend implementation
  • Test coverage
  • Documentation
  • Deployment/Infrastructure

Evidence Collection

Placeholder Files

Look for files indicating incomplete work:

# Find TODO/WIP/PLACEHOLDER files
find . -iname "*todo*" -o -iname "*wip*" -o -iname "*placeholder*" -o -iname "*draft*" 2>/dev/null \
  | grep -v "node_modules\|\.git"

# Find empty or near-empty files
find . -type f -size 0 2>/dev/null | grep -v "node_modules\|\.git\|\.keep"

# Files with just placeholders
find . -type f -name "*.ts" -o -name "*.tsx" -o -name "*.js" -o -name "*.jsx" 2>/dev/null \
  | xargs grep -l "TODO\|FIXME\|PLACEHOLDER\|XXX\|HACK" \
  | head -20

README Mentions

# Search README for incomplete features
grep -i "todo\|wip\|work in progress\|coming soon\|not yet\|planned\|roadmap\|incomplete" README.md 2>/dev/null

Code Comments

# Count TODO/FIXME comments
grep -r "TODO\|FIXME\|XXX\|HACK" src/ 2>/dev/null | wc -l

# Show sample TODOs
grep -r "TODO\|FIXME" src/ 2>/dev/null | head -10

Component-Specific Assessment

Backend Completeness

Check for:

  1. API Endpoints

    # Count API routes
find . -path "*/api/*" -o -path "*/routes/*" 2>/dev/null | wc -l

# Find routes with placeholder responses
grep -r "res.json({})\|return {}\|NotImplementedError" src/api/ src/routes/ 2>/dev/null

  2. Business Logic

    # Count service/controller files
find . -path "*/services/*" -o -path "*/controllers/*" 2>/dev/null | wc -l

# Find stub implementations
grep -r "throw new Error.*not implemented\|NotImplementedError" src/ 2>/dev/null

  3. Database

    # Check if migrations are applied
ls -la prisma/migrations/ 2>/dev/null | wc -l

# Check for empty seed files
ls -la prisma/seed.ts 2>/dev/null

  4. Authentication

    # Check for auth middleware
find . -name "*auth*" -o -name "*session*" | grep -v node_modules

# Look for JWT/session handling
grep -r "jwt\|jsonwebtoken\|express-session\|passport" package.json src/ 2>/dev/null

Estimate:

  • 100% = All endpoints implemented, tested, documented
  • 75% = All endpoints exist, some missing tests/validation
  • 50% = Core endpoints done, advanced features missing
  • 25% = Skeleton only, most logic unimplemented
  • 0% = No backend implementation

Frontend Completeness

Check for:

  1. Pages/Views

    # Count pages
find . -path "*/pages/*" -o -path "*/app/*" -o -path "*/views/*" 2>/dev/null \
  | grep -E "\.(tsx?|jsx?|vue)$" | wc -l

# Find placeholder pages
grep -r "Coming Soon\|Under Construction\|TODO\|Placeholder" app/ pages/ components/ 2>/dev/null

  2. Components

    # Count components
find . -path "*/components/*" | grep -E "\.(tsx?|jsx?|vue)$" | wc -l

# Find stub components
grep -r "return null\|return <div>TODO\|placeholder" components/ 2>/dev/null

  3. Styling

    # Check for styling setup
ls -la tailwind.config.* 2>/dev/null
find . -name "*.css" -o -name "*.scss" 2>/dev/null | head -10

# Check if components are styled
grep -r "className\|style=" components/ 2>/dev/null | wc -l

  4. State Management

    # Check for state management
grep -r "redux\|zustand\|recoil\|jotai\|mobx" package.json 2>/dev/null
grep -r "createContext\|useContext" src/ app/ 2>/dev/null | wc -l

Estimate:

  • 100% = All pages implemented, styled, interactive
  • 75% = All pages exist, some missing polish/interactivity
  • 50% = Core pages done, advanced features missing
  • 25% = Skeleton pages, minimal styling/functionality
  • 0% = No frontend implementation

Testing Completeness

Check for:

  1. Test Files

    # Count test files
find . -name "*.test.*" -o -name "*.spec.*" 2>/dev/null | wc -l

# Count tests
grep -r "test(\|it(\|describe(" tests/ __tests__/ src/ 2>/dev/null | wc -l

  2. Test Coverage

    # Check for coverage reports
ls -la coverage/ 2>/dev/null

# Check test configuration
ls -la jest.config.* vitest.config.* 2>/dev/null

  3. Test Types

    # Unit tests
find . -path "*/tests/unit/*" -o -name "*.unit.test.*" 2>/dev/null | wc -l

# Integration tests
find . -path "*/tests/integration/*" -o -name "*.integration.test.*" 2>/dev/null | wc -l

# E2E tests
find . -path "*/tests/e2e/*" -o -name "*.e2e.*" -o -name "cypress/" -o -name "playwright/" 2>/dev/null

Estimate:

  • 100% = >80% code coverage, unit + integration + E2E tests
  • 75% = 60-80% coverage, unit + integration tests
  • 50% = 40-60% coverage, mostly unit tests
  • 25% = <40% coverage, sparse unit tests
  • 0% = No tests

Documentation Completeness

Use findings from documentation-scan.md:

Estimate:

  • 100% = README, API docs, architecture, deployment, developer guide, all current
  • 75% = README + API docs + some architecture/deployment docs
  • 50% = Good README, partial API docs
  • 25% = Basic README only
  • 0% = No meaningful documentation

Infrastructure/Deployment Completeness

Check for:

  1. Infrastructure as Code

    # Check for IaC files
find . -name "*.tf" -o -name "serverless.yml" -o -name "cdk.json" 2>/dev/null

# Count resources defined
grep -r "resource\|AWS::" infrastructure/ terraform/ 2>/dev/null | wc -l

  2. CI/CD

    # GitHub Actions
ls -la .github/workflows/ 2>/dev/null

# Other CI/CD
ls -la .gitlab-ci.yml .circleci/config.yml .travis.yml 2>/dev/null

  3. Environment Configuration

    # Environment files
ls -la .env.example .env.template 2>/dev/null

# Environment validation
grep -r "dotenv\|env-var\|envalid" package.json src/ 2>/dev/null

  4. Deployment Scripts

    # Deployment scripts
find . -name "deploy.sh" -o -name "deploy.js" -o -name "deploy.ts" 2>/dev/null

# Package scripts
grep "deploy\|build\|start\|test" package.json 2>/dev/null

Estimate:

  • 100% = Full IaC, CI/CD, monitoring, auto-deployment
  • 75% = IaC + CI/CD, manual deployment
  • 50% = Basic CI/CD, no IaC
  • 25% = Manual deployment only
  • 0% = No deployment setup

Overall Completeness Calculation

Calculate weighted average:

Overall = (Backend × 0.3) + (Frontend × 0.3) + (Tests × 0.2) + (Docs × 0.1) + (Infra × 0.1)

Example:

  • Backend: 100%
  • Frontend: 60%
  • Tests: 30%
  • Docs: 40%
  • Infra: 80%

Overall = (100 × 0.3) + (60 × 0.3) + (30 × 0.2) + (40 × 0.1) + (80 × 0.1) = 30 + 18 + 6 + 4 + 8 = 66%

Missing Components Identification

List what's missing or incomplete:

High Priority:

  • Frontend: User profile page (placeholder only)
  • Frontend: Analytics dashboard (not started)
  • Backend: Email notification service (stub)
  • Tests: Integration tests for API (0 tests)
  • Docs: API specification (no OpenAPI)

Medium Priority:

  • Frontend: Mobile responsive design (partially done)
  • Backend: Rate limiting (not implemented)
  • Tests: E2E tests (no framework setup)
  • Infra: Monitoring/alerting (not configured)

Low Priority:

  • Frontend: Dark mode (placeholder toggle)
  • Backend: Admin panel API (not started)
  • Docs: Troubleshooting guide (missing)

Evidence Summary

Document the evidence used for estimates:

### Evidence

**Backend (100%):**
- 17 Lambda functions fully implemented
- All database models defined and migrated
- Authentication and authorization complete
- API endpoints tested and documented

**Frontend (60%):**
- 8 of 12 planned pages implemented
- Core components complete (Header, Footer, Nav)
- 4 pages are placeholder/TODO:
  - Analytics Dashboard (TODO comment in code)
  - User Settings (returns "Coming Soon")
  - Admin Panel (not started)
  - Reports (skeleton only)
- Styling ~80% complete

**Tests (30%):**
- 12 unit tests for backend utilities
- 0 integration tests
- 0 E2E tests
- No test coverage reports
- jest.config.js exists but minimal tests

**Documentation (40%):**
- Good README with setup instructions
- No API documentation (no OpenAPI spec)
- No architecture diagrams
- Basic deployment guide
- No developer guide

**Infrastructure (80%):**
- Full Terraform IaC for AWS
- GitHub Actions CI/CD configured
- Auto-deploy to staging
- Manual production deploy
- No monitoring/alerting setup

Output Format

## Completeness Assessment

### Estimated Completion
- **Overall:** ~66%
- **Backend:** ~100%
- **Frontend:** ~60%
- **Tests:** ~30%
- **Documentation:** ~40%
- **Infrastructure:** ~80%

### Evidence
[Detailed evidence as shown above]

### Missing Components
[Categorized list of missing/incomplete features]

### Placeholder Files
- app/analytics/page.tsx (TODO comment)
- app/settings/page.tsx ("Coming Soon" text)
- src/services/email.ts (stub functions)

### TODO Comments
- Found 23 TODO/FIXME comments across codebase
- Most common: Frontend polish, missing tests, error handling

Notes

  • Be conservative with estimates - round down when uncertain
  • Provide evidence for all estimates
  • Consider quality, not just quantity (a poorly implemented feature counts less)
  • Differentiate between "not started" vs "partially done" vs "mostly complete"
Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink