Initial commit

assets/analysis-template.md

@@ -0,0 +1,204 @@
+# Third Pass Analysis Template
+
+Use this template structure for consistent Third Pass analysis output.
+
+## Standard Format
+
+```markdown
+### Third-Pass
+
+#### Critical Analysis
+- **주장의 약점 / 적용 한계**
+  - [Specific weakness 1: explain the issue]
+  - [Specific weakness 2: where this approach fails]
+  - [Generalization limits: boundaries of applicability]
+
+- **컨텍스트 의존성 (환경, 스택, 시기)**
+  - Environment: [Tech stack, scale, constraints assumed]
+  - Prerequisites: [Knowledge, tools, or resources required]
+  - Temporal: [Time-sensitive assumptions or dated information]
+  - Cultural: [Organizational, regional, or domain-specific factors]
+
+- **누락된 관점 / 대안**
+  - Alternatives: [Other approaches not explored]
+  - Trade-offs: [Costs or sacrifices not discussed]
+  - Contrary views: [Opposing arguments or debates]
+  - Edge cases: [Scenarios not addressed]
+
+#### Reconstruction
+- **핵심을 나만의 언어로**
+  - [Restate the central thesis and key supporting ideas]
+  - [Explain the logical flow or architecture]
+  - [Capture the "why" behind the approach]
+
+- **내 상황에 적용한다면**
+  - 직접 적용: [What can be adopted as-is, why it fits]
+  - 변형 필요: [What needs modification, how to adapt it]
+  - 적용 불가: [What doesn't fit, why not, what to do instead]
+
+#### Discussion
+- **가져갈 것**
+  - [Most valuable insights to remember and apply]
+  - [Specific actions or changes to make]
+
+- **한계**
+  - [Boundaries of applicability]
+  - [Remaining questions or uncertainties]
+  - [Situations where caution is needed]
+
+#### Action Items
+- [ ] [Specific action item or experiment to try]
+- [ ] [Related concept or document to explore]
+- [ ] [Validation step before applying]
+
+#### Future Ideas
+- [ ] [Follow-up research or investigation]
+- [ ] [Related question to explore]
+```
+
+## Variation for Tech Blog
+
+```markdown
+### Third-Pass
+
+#### Critical Analysis
+- **Technical Limitations**
+  - Problem scope: [What problems this doesn't solve]
+  - Scale considerations: [Where performance/complexity becomes issue]
+  - Trade-offs: [What's sacrificed for benefits gained]
+
+- **Implementation Context**
+  - Stack requirements: [Languages, frameworks, tools needed]
+  - Prerequisites: [Existing infrastructure or knowledge]
+  - Assumed scale: [Team size, user load, data volume]
+
+- **Alternatives & Edge Cases**
+  - Simpler approaches: [When to use something simpler]
+  - Alternative solutions: [Other ways to solve this]
+  - Edge cases: [Scenarios where this breaks]
+
+#### Reconstruction
+- **Technical Approach**
+  - [Explain the solution architecture in own words]
+
+- **Applying to My Stack**
+  - 직접 적용: [Components that transfer as-is]
+  - 변형 필요: [What to modify for my environment]
+  - 다른 접근: [Where I'd do something different]
+
+#### Discussion
+- **Worth Adopting**
+  - [Specific techniques or patterns to use]
+
+- **Watch Out For**
+  - [Gotchas, anti-patterns, or risks]
+
+#### Action Items
+- [ ] Test with small prototype
+- [ ] Benchmark against current approach
+- [ ] Read [related article/docs]
+```
+
+## Variation for Retrospective
+
+```markdown
+### Third-Pass
+
+#### Critical Analysis
+- **Context Specificity**
+  - Team context: [What's unique about their team/org]
+  - Situational factors: [Circumstances that affected outcomes]
+  - Generalizability: [Where lessons may not apply]
+
+- **Success Factors**
+  - What they controlled: [Decisions and actions]
+  - What they didn't: [Luck, timing, external factors]
+  - Key enablers: [What made success possible]
+
+- **Unstated Lessons**
+  - Reading between lines: [Implicit insights]
+  - Missing perspectives: [Other team members' views]
+  - Survivorship bias: [What about failed attempts?]
+
+#### Reconstruction
+- **Key Lessons**
+  - [Core takeaways in own words]
+
+- **Relevance to My Situation**
+  - 직접 적용: [Lessons that transfer to my context]
+  - 변형 필요: [How to adapt for my situation]
+  - 적용 불가: [What's too context-specific]
+
+#### Discussion
+- **Actionable Insights**
+  - [Changes to make based on this]
+
+- **Caveats**
+  - [Limitations of lessons learned]
+
+#### Action Items
+- [ ] Apply [specific practice] on next project
+- [ ] Validate [assumption] in my context
+- [ ] Discuss with team
+```
+
+## Variation for Academic Paper
+
+```markdown
+### Third-Pass
+
+#### Critical Analysis
+- **Methodological Issues**
+  - Design limitations: [Threats to validity]
+  - Sample issues: [Size, representativeness, bias]
+  - Alternative explanations: [Other ways to interpret results]
+
+- **Assumptions & Scope**
+  - Theoretical assumptions: [Framework dependencies]
+  - Boundary conditions: [Where findings don't apply]
+  - Generalizability: [Population, setting, time]
+
+- **Research Gaps**
+  - Missing variables: [What wasn't considered]
+  - Unexplored angles: [Related questions not asked]
+  - Future work: [What needs investigation]
+
+#### Reconstruction
+- **Research Contribution**
+  - [Main findings and their significance]
+
+- **Application to Practice**
+  - 실무 적용: [How this informs real-world decisions]
+  - 후속 연구: [Follow-up studies this enables]
+  - 내 연구: [How this relates to my work]
+
+#### Discussion
+- **Key Findings**
+  - [Most important results]
+
+- **Limitations**
+  - [Validity threats and boundaries]
+
+#### Action Items
+- [ ] Replicate with [different population/setting]
+- [ ] Extend to [related phenomenon]
+- [ ] Address [limitation] in future study
+```
+
+## Usage Notes
+
+**Adapt the template:**
+- Not every section is needed for every document
+- Combine sections when appropriate
+- Add subsections for complex analysis
+- Use bullet points with bold headings for clear structure
+
+**Maintain consistency:**
+- Use same structure across similar documents
+- This enables easy comparison later
+- Makes it easier to find information
+
+**Be concise but complete:**
+- Each point should be specific and actionable
+- Avoid vague statements
+- Include enough context to understand later